1.Teriyaki Chicken Wings

2. Mussels Pomodoro

-New Zealand mussels, chopped tomatoes, and sauage in a white wine garlic sauce with a touch of marinara, topped with chili flakes

3. Stuffed Mushrooms

4. Buffalo Calamari topped with blue cheese

5. Zucchini Salad

Grilled zucchini and squash, peppers, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers and olives served with a homemade italian lemon dressing (olive oil. vinagar, lemon)

Dinner Entrees

1.  Chicken Hawleyville
-Artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and sundried tomatos in a brown sauce served with your choice of pasta

2.  Stuffed Rigatoni
-served in a vodka or pesto sauce

3.Greek Penne
-sauteed red onions, spinach, garlic and oil topped with feta cheese

4.Pomodoro Style New Zealand Mussels and Shrimp

-served with linguine in a white wine garlic sauce with a touch of pomodoro

5. Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Ravioli
-sherry cream sauce and diced tomatoes

6. Chicken Saltimbocca

-sauteed chicken with spinach and mushrooms in a marsala sauce topped with provolone cheese

7. Combo Special

-Chicken and Stuffed Sole in a francaise sauce served with veggies and your choice of pasta

8. Homemade Regular Gnocchi alla Romano

-with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese


Get a FREE desert AND 2 liter soda with purchase of 2 large cheese pizzas!

(Available Monday,Tuesday, and Wednesday)


Lunch Specials


Buffalo Burger:

With pepperjcak cheese, buffalo sauce, lettuce and tomato,served with a side of fries

BBQ Chicken Wrap:

Grilled BBQ chicken, grilled mushrooms, red onions, red peppers, hot cherry peppers and ranch dressing

Southwest Wrap:

Chicken cutlet, spicy southwest sauce, provelone, lettuce and tomato


As of December 21st, we will be delivering to parts of Newtown, Danbury, Bethel, and Brookfield!


Sun-Thurs: 11 am-8:45 pm

Fri-Sat: 11 am-9:15 pm

$15.00 Minimum

*up to a 4 miles


****Beer & and Wine now being served!! Cheers****

“Valentines Day Specials”

dinner for two- $39.95  includes appetizer, bottle of wine,and choice of entree

-grilled salmon, shrimp francese, talapia francese, stuffed sole, cavatelli chicken & broccoli, chicken san remo

fish pic chick mushroom

Welcome to Papa Al’s, Italian Food Done Right!

Welcome to Papa Al’s, Italian Food Done Right!

Welcome to Papa Al’s, where you’ll enjoy Italian food done right. We cook up mouthwatering thin crust Italian style and Sicilian pies, delicious pasta lunches and dinners and a wide variety of subs, salads, appetizers, wraps, paninis, burgers, calzones and more for your tasting pleasure.  Conveniently located next to the Hawleyville Post Office on Barnabas Road in Newtown, just off exit 9 off of I-84, Papa Al’s is open daily for lunch and dinner.

  • Hours of Operation: Mon – Thu, 11am – 9pm; Fri – Sat, 11am – 9:30pm; Sun, 1pm-9pm
  • Payments accepted: American Express, Cash, MasterCard, Visa, Discover
  • General services: Eat-in, Take-out
  • Parking: Free lot
  • Cuisine: Italian, Pizza, Sandwiches
  • Features: Lunch, Dinner, Kid’s Menu, Group-friendly